Showing posts with label court. Show all posts
Showing posts with label court. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Holding My Breath

Due to The Boy's second day of appointments, I am unable to go up to court with my sister today.  I find she is on my mind at every turn, however.  She is headed back to repond to her ex's request for a change in custody for their older son.  Apparently, the boys' dad figures the younger son is a hopeless cause, as he doesn't seem interested in having custody of him.  Just the older boy.

My older nephew is 15 and seems to be a high ranking minion in his father's apparent plans for domination.  He has been swayed over the last five years or so to, I believe, begin to subscribe to his dad's ideas that my sister--his mom--is the cause of all their troubles.  He has gotten into his own mess with the law after assaulting my sister in her home when he didn't get his way.  Echoes of his dad's behavior, I think.  His dad has gone out of his way to make my sister's life miserable, and is using his own don to do much of his bidding.  For me that is wrong, on many levels.

In addition to the mother-son conflict that the ex has orchestrated, he has also pulled in his sister and his parents to act on his behalf.  My sister has had DCFS called on her, now three separate times, with claims of neglect, abuse, and generally poor parenting.  In each of the now dismissed cases, there was no fault found on her part.  I hope that comes up today in court.

My breath is held each time she has to deal with the legal issues in her lap.  With this finally be the tiem the court opens its objectively blind eye to the injustice that is going on and finally take action that will be permanent and lasting?  Will this be the hearing that will finally put things to rest so my sister can move on with the rest of her life and that will give her the upper hand in getting her boys the help they both still (and in some cases, desperately) need professionally?  Will the costly legal battle come to an end?  And will her ex actually be held accountable for the destruction he has left in his wake?

I once had a lot of stock in the legal system, but so far--over the five years I have been witness to her experiences there--I am not so impressed.  This is not to say I'd prefer the legal system of any other country.  But there is much that hasn't lived up to my idealistc view of American justice and civil law.  And that is why my insides get so churned up when she has to go back for these ridiculous hearings.

Knowing she has to deal with it day in and day out makes me feel bad for her, but at the same time, incredibly grateful I am just a supporter of her situation.  I am more an observer, and less a participant--though I worry regularly about her well being, and that of my nephews.  that will never change, no matter what the judge decides.  If he ever decides.

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Frustration and Discouragement: Must be a Court Week

I go to court with my sister on Thursday.  This hearing is to settle some child-support issues, as well as the unpaid debts that her ex has still not paid off--that have her name connected to it--after four and a half years of divorce.  Plus the ex was ordered to get some psychiatric counseling by a PhD who knows how to deal with people with classic narcissism.

She just found out her ex has filed for bankruptcy. 

Consequently, this whole court ordeal might be for naught.  He will be allowed to leave the consumer debts he still hasn't paid off.  He may even be allowed to walk away from court and legal fees he was ordered to pay when she was awarded them by the court.  Four and a half year's worth of  battling, and even the winning, may be swept away after all.

And who knows if child support is demanded from someone who files for bankruptcy and won't hold down a job?  The kids still need the financial support.  The kids still need the counseling.  The kids still need to eat, and be clothed, and be cared for with medical attention when needed.  The kids will still want to do things they always have--football, baseball, scouts.  All that costs money.  Money that should be provided for them by both of their parents.

I know my sister is doing all she can.  She is a teacher and makes a teacher's salary.  I guess it is lucky that at least she has medical insurance that covers the boys, but that costs her too.  Costs that should be shared.  She worries about their future...college, missions, marriage, mental and physical health; not to mention her own future...retirement, long term health, debts.  It adds up quick.  And it all costs money.  Money that should not just be her responsibility.  The boys are his too.

But I guess it could always be worse.  Something could happen to my sister and if she were gone, these boys would go to their dad full time.  Then what would happen to to them?  I don't even what to think about it.

So, I'll pop some more Imodium, and drive to Ogden, and sit through another pointless hour or so where the judge is impotent in his ruling because this man has learned not only how to manipulate everyone in his life, but now also the legal system and all its parts; where my sister will have to pay, again, this time knowing her awarded fees and costs will never be repaid and her boys will still be getting the short end of the stick while she deals with their emotional outbursts and all their needs.  That is not right.

Friday, December 10, 2010

Another Day in Court

Yesterday I spent several hours as moral support to my sister at another child custody court hearing.  She and her ex-husband have been divorced for four years, and yet, we were still trying to make things better between them--it takes a judge's mandate--and for the boys.

The big judge who signed their divorce decree heard them this time, as it was called in objection to three orders made by the commissioner, the big-judge's underling.

The first objection was over the commissioner's decision to remove the parent-coordinator from this case.  The Ex believes she was biased against him.  The big judge affirmed that decision, but called for another parent-coordinator to be assigned.  He recognized that these two parents are currently unable to positively co-parent without some mediation. 

This will be the fourth professional assigned to their situation.  The first quit after The Ex threatened him.  The second was doing the custody evaluation and reported that this was the worst case of parental-alienation he had seen in his 20+ years of practice.  And now this third doctor is removed, after suggesting The Ex do things to improve his relationship with the boys and my sister that The Ex didn't like and was belligerent about that.  Sure, I can see where she reported that he was uncooperative, and had an "increased sense of entitlement" that made it difficult to do her job.  But he was that as a biased take.

I feel sorry for whomever they select to have to work with this family.

The other two issues were about money.  Of course.

First, they objected to was the financial issue of splitting the cost of transporting the boys to their dad's place, now 300 miles away.  The judge ruled that that will stand, but added that since The Ex owes my sister exponentially more money that that portion he requested her to pay for the transporting of the the boys, she will not have to pay any transportation costs until his outstanding fees, court decisions, and debts to her are paid in full.

And finally, after the custody shifted to their mom, and their dad finally has a job after not working fr much of the 12 years they were married and the majority of time since the divorce, the child support needed to be adjusted.  The judge ruled that the attorneys use the standard child custody worksheet (how sad that this even exists?!) be used and submitted, and the support be adjusted accordingly.

We were there for an hour and 45 minutes.  At one point the judge faced down The Ex and told him, point blank, ordered that he get a therapist or counselor in 15 days and get in to see that professional to begin to make the necessary adjustments needed to improve this situation.  He told both of them, that he really didn't want o see them again, but they have a standing appointment in 90 days to review the progress The Ex makes in the therapeutic help.  And if he fails to listen and obey this order, he will go to jail--in contempt of court.

I will believe it when I see that.  We have heard that from the commissioner regularly.  I've yet to see any action taken against him.  It just costs more money, and more time, and more effort to present their irritations AGAIN in court.  That is the most frustrating part.  I have lost a lot of faith in the system since this divorce and the fall out we've witnessed since.  There is a lot of bark, but no bite.

I'm glad to only have to 'live it" once in a while, when I show up for the court proceedings.  But it breaks my heart that my nephews are the ones really paying for the behavior and decisions of their parents.  I appreciate the things that, as a parent, my sister has done to do better for her boys.  I know it has cost her a lot of money and stress, and tears and worry.  But that is what you do when you are a parent.  The moment that child is yours, your wishes take a back seat to theirs. 

I wish all parents understood that idea, and acted on it.  How much happier children would be, if we did.

Thursday, May 28, 2009

Where's Perry Mason When You Need Him?

Our visit to court yesterday was not the regular diarrhea inducing event it usually is but it wasn't a reason to party yet either.

I believe if everything goes as outlined by the court representatives before the commissioner yesterday, the summer will continue with the boys in shared custody--one week with dad, one week with mom--and 13 year old nephew J has been prescribed madatory weekly, you-will-not-miss-it counseling all summer! Hallelujah for that. He has needed it for almost 3 years now and has not been meeting with a counselor on his own at all.

At the end of the summer the Guardian Ad Litem will make a ruling at to how the custody will be settled, once and for all. Both parents agreed before the commissioner--twice int eh case of my sister's ex--that they understand the ruling will be a final, court-ordered, you-must-live-by-this decision. By both agreeing to live by the GAL's decision, no trial will need to be held, no extra twelve months of hearings, no more open artery of money going out to pay for this circus. It will be done.

So long as the Guardian Ad Litem sticks to his guns.

When Sister talked to him, she told him that she cannot do this any more: physically, her health has deteriorated over the past 3 years and mentally, she is wiped out. Financially, this has been more than a drain as well and she worries about that too.

In response to that, the GAL told her that HE can't stand to do this case any more and wants it done too. I don't think he believed, when he first took this case, that this situation was a messed up as it really has been. There are a lot of issues--manipulation, abuse, immaturity, coercion, narcissism--that are not exposed at first glance. I think it is tiring for him to deal with as well.

So, he has told her that the only way he would not recommend her having full custody--remember, that is what his motion before the court was originally yesterday--would be if counselling for nephew J, forced co-parenting counseling for the ex-BIL, and the shared custody were all "working". He told Sister that the chance of that happening in this screwed up family is next to none.

So, baby steps forward are still forward steps, I figure. But I was sure hoping that the commissioner would just throw the book at this dad who hasn't held a job for almost 8 years and makes some of the lamest and craziest excuses I have ever heard--with a straight face, believing he is winning. What a nut job.

Hey, maybe this is more Night Court than Perry Mason. That would definitely fit the situation.

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Heigh Ho, Heigh Ho....

It's off to court I go....today....again.

This system, I know, is the best in the world. But the process can be tedious and glacier-slow. This will be the third scheduled date for this hearing. The two previous were postponed. In April, it was postponed due to a change in my ex-BIL's representation (read: his attorney dropped him for not paying his bill.) At the beginning of this month, it was postponed because a new motion was being filed that would ask the court to change the physical and legal custody of the children to be fully my sister's. We will see what we get today.

I don't know how any reasonably sane person would choose to go into law and then specialize in family law when the drama is so high and the progress is so slow. I would be either anorexic or weigh 500 pounds just from the stress.

I guess, today is as good as any other day. I am still feeling the lingering illness that comes with the flu, so no difference than any other day in court. Upset stomach, aching joints and muscles, cloudy thoughts. Yeah. The flu is just like going to court. Same physical manifestations.

Boy, I love my life. You are jealous, aren't you?!

Thursday, May 7, 2009

What NOW?!

I was prepared and calm about going to court yesterday with Sister, again. This date was the second try for this hearing as the original date during Spring break had been postponed because her ex no longer had an attorney to represent him.

Yesterday, just a half hour before we were scheduled for the hearing, her attorney called and told her it was put off again, three more weeks. But this time, it sounds like the people involved--attorneys, guardian ad litem, counselors--are pushing a little harder for some actual change.

I have since quit expecting any action to be taken, but I always hope, for her sake.

Why to things have to take so long when there are people, especially children, who have their health, mental wellness and emotional well being hanging in the balance? Why does the system move so slowly? Why doesn't the system really show its teeth when the action has been requested?

This two and a half year process is perpetually irritating to me. I become physically ill when I go to these hearings with her. There is so much contention in that room, I can barely stand it. I also feel the sense of deception from her ex as he tries to persuade and manipulate the courts system to his way of thinking. This situation is wrong. Why can't the powers that be see that!? And why won't they look at what this is doing to the kids involved? These boys are not getting the help they really need to deal with their new circumstances.

I wish I could just grab the commissioner and shake him and ask him these questions. So far, no answers. I do see the toll it takes on my sister and my family. Yesterday morning, in fact, The Boy was saying our morning family prayer ans asked Heavenly Father to bless mom that "going to court won't mess her up." I appreciated his sentiments, but obviously is affects me enough to, in turn, affect my family.

I look forward to her next hearing. The physical symptoms I usually see at court didn't occur this time and I hope that is a new trend. Heaven knows, we could use some change with this situation.

Thursday, December 18, 2008

6th Day of Christmas...6 of One; Half Dozen of the Other

One week from today is Christmas. How does that happen? Wasn't it just Easter? 4th of July? Halloween? Life just gets crazier all the time. But I digress...

Have you ever heard the colloquialism "Six of one, half dozen of the other"? This isn't something I grew up hearing, but now that I have heard it, and been using it on occasion even, the more I like it. To me, this means, it is the same. Not a big difference.

For example, if I ask, 'Which way is the fastest way to get there?' and you answer 'It's sixes', I will know that both suggested traveling plans are pretty equal and either way is good enough to get there.

Now my thoughts for today's post isn't about travel. But it is about equality, or rather, no difference in outcome.

Yesterday I spent the majority of my day in a courtroom in Ogden for yet another custody hearing for my sister and her kids. This is an on going, just over two year long, terrifically ugly, full blown fight for the custody of her two boys, ages 12 and 9.

In past court hearings I have always thought these boys need to be with their mom, full time. But after yesterday, I don't know that it matters. I think it might be "sixes".

I understand that these are my nephews--my only ones from my side of the family. But I also know that they are two very messed up kids, due to the misery they have lived with for the past few years. I also know that they will need a lot of professional help, of which they haven't even begun yet, to hope to recover someday.

For a while I thought maybe the court would suggest a Solomon like proposal--dad take one boy and mom take the other boy. That didn't happen. Any maybe that would not be fair to the boys themselves. But the constant fighting and bickering, selfishness and nastiness isn't any better for them.

Instead, the two parties agreed to abide by the custody evaluator's suggestions. Shared custody. 50%. Two days with mom and 2 days with dad and weekends alternated. Luckily mom and dad both live in the boundaries of the same schools.

But after two years of court and thousands of dollars of in legal fees and payments, essentially they are back to what they had originally, verbally agreed to when they divorced. And the kids are still the losers.

To me, it is 6 of One; Half Dozen of the Other. And it breaks my heart.