Remember a couple weeks ago when I wrote about the Olympic oath that athlete's symbolically take before the games begin? Remember what it says:
"In the name of all
the competitors, I promise that we shall take part in these Olympic
Games, respecting and abiding by the rules which govern them, committing
ourselves to a sport without doping and without drugs, in the true
spirit of sportsmanship, for the glory of sport and the honor of our
teams."
--The Olympic Oath
Each of the Olympians, in my simple mind, went into the games with this kind of thinking--do the very best I am able, without any short cuts or corner cutting. In other words: no cheating. I thought that was the basic Olympic ideal. I guess that isn't true for everyone.
In all my swimming enjoyment last week, I was thrilled to see a South African, named Cameron, do so well in the breaststroke. I happen to know another kid named Cameron who likes the breaststroke. Anyways, this week the news story below showed up on my Yahoo home page in the news of the Olympics.
South African gold medalist Cameron van der Burgh admitted to taking
extra underwater kicks during his 100-meter breaststroke victory last
week at the Olympics, an illegal move that would have earned him a
disqualification if the judges on deck had seen it.
Swimmers are allowed one underwater dolphin kick during their
underwater breaststroke pullouts. Replays show Van der Burgh took three
on the start.
He told the Sydney Morning Herald that he took extra kicks, but says he’s not the only one.
”If you’re not doing it, you’re falling behind,” he said. “It’s not
obviously – shall we say – the moral thing to do, but I’m not willing to
sacrifice my personal performance and four years of hard work for
someone that is willing to do it and get away with it.”
Allowing dolphin kicks during breaststroke is relatively new. The
rules were changed, in part, because of four-time gold medalist Kosuke
Kitajima, a Japanese breaststroke star who routinely added rogue kicks
to his underwater. These kicks angered rivals, like American, Brendan
Hansen. Then the rule was changed to allow one. But the old “give ‘em an
inch” rule came into play and now breast strokers are trying to sneak in
as many kicks as possible, hoping to do it without drawing the
attention of officials.
”It’s got to the sort of point where if you’re not doing it you’re
falling behind or your giving yourself a disadvantage so everyone’s
pushing the rules and pushing the boundaries, so if you’re not doing it,
you’re not trying hard enough,” the South African said.
Van der Burgh can get away with the kicks because there is no
underwater video review of swimming races. After testing the technology
at a meet in 2010, FINA, the international swimming body, has yet to
incorporate it in international meets.
After these comments and the potential uproar they’ll create, expect that to change by next year’s world championships.
You see why it is upsetting, don't you? This kid "won" the gold medal by cheating, and then has the audacity to justify himself by saying things like this happen all the time--everyone is doing it--so he shouldn't be penalized. I know of several young swimmers who end up disqualified each summer for doing too many dolphin kicks, to their pull-downs go too low, or they didn't touch the wall with both hands. And you know what? It usually only takes one DQ to figure out how to do it right. As a summer recreation team, our coached, stroke judges, and meet officials go out of their way to TEACH the kids who to do it properly so they aren't DQed next time. Because as adults int he program, we care about the kids' swimming abilities, but also for their moral uprightness.
That really sad thing is they have the proof on video...but with swimming the actual physical human beings who are acting as stroke judges are the only ones who can DQ a swimmer. There are no instant replay options, like in other sports. Yet, this kid finked on himself, but had no intention of turning in a gold medal he had not really earned.
Too bad. He suddenly no longer fits the Olympic ideal in my mind. He's lost a fan, he's lost respect, and he's lost his integrity. And it is his loss.