Monday, September 28, 2009

Youth Leadership

Yesterday I was made aware of a situation in The Boy's deacon's quorum at church. Two situations, really. Neither one is what I would have expected.

Apparently, since The Boy turned twelve in April, the handful of boys have been teaching the Sunday lessons, except on Fast Sunday when a counselor in the Bishopric teaches them. What do 12 year olds know enough of to teach their peers?! How do 12 year olds concentrate that hard on a topic in order to be prepared to teach?! If The Boy has had to take a turn in this preposterous idea why hasn't he had any lesson manual to follow?! The majority of the suuposed lesson time, they are planning their scout activities for the week. Is that what is supposed to happen in priesthood meetings?!

Genius Golfer was called two weeks ago as an assistant Scout Master and as such was asked to sit in on the Deacon's Quorum lessons on Sunday. Yesterday, GG discovered, The Boy (who is the Quorum secretary) forgot to call one of the other boys to remind him that the lesson was his responsibility. So the leader who is implementing this program told The Boy "since you forgot to call him you can teach the lesson". Uh. I don't think so. GG was stunned. He came home from church and asked me if this was normal. Uhhh, no way Jose.

The other issue was the youth in our ward are preparing the annual Golden Age Dinner for this week's activity. They plan a dinner and invite the more senior members of the ward to join them. The idea is some intergenerational cooperation and increased love and concern for our youth to have towards our older members. Apparently this same leader who has the boys teach, assigned this entire event to these same boys--who have never even been to one of these dinners before. The newest Deacon was given charge of the entire thing--menu planning, shopping, budget, etc. Talk about a lot of stress on a young boy! That is crazy!

Even The Boy had an assignment, but nothing like our little deacon friend, C. In talking with C's mom last evening, she said her boy was feeling the weight of the world in this assignment. No guidance was given, and no assistance was offered. Worse yet, the Young Men have blown through their budget for the year and have no money to spend on this event. The Young Women have offered to help kick in monetarily (and would be willing to help any other ways too, if they were asked). But then the boys must respect that they are spending other's people's activity money. That is a lot of stress for a 12 year old boy, no matter who it is.

I get it that as leaders of youth we are here to teach them leadership skills, but the 'drop them into the deep end to teach them to swim' theory is not a method I would advise. Maybe GG's new calling there is really one of supervisor and advocate for these boys. Who knows, at this point. But I was hot yesterday as all this came to light. With experiences like these as a 12 year old, can you blame these kids for not showing interest in the church activities by the time they are 15?

I'll keep you posted. And I'll try to keep my tongue.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

Oh...how I wish I could give you hope. There's just not much coming. My boys, all 3 started at 12 with no supervision, no help. For 3 years straight the Young Men's night consisted of their leader letting them into the Church, then turning them loose to play basketball. Leader then disappeared. We never ever knew who the Scout Leader was, it changed monthly ('Course, that could just be THE Church of Orem...) :)

Taffy said...

DH said the 2nd counselor is the scout master unless your ward does it differently.
He also said the mom of the new deacon should call the counselor in the bishopric who is over YM and let them know what happened.