Wednesday, July 6, 2011

The Legendary Potato Salad Escapade

It might not be legendary yet, but some day it will be.  I'm sure of it.  But to truly understand this weekend's Potato Salad Escapade, you must first know the back story.

When Genius Golfer and I married, I began to understand I joined a family of women who were great cooks, sewed beautifully, and were creative and crafty and amazing.  Immediately I felt I was in over my head.  One of the first family events I attended as a newlywed was a family BBQ for some reason or another.  My good mother-in-law asked if I'd like to bring something.  I said "Sure," wanting to show my enthusiasm for my new family and my competancy in preparing a side dish which everyone would enjoy.  I told her my mom made the best potato salad, so I'd love to bring that.

Being so excited to do this, and thus looking for acceptance by my in-laws, and holding, deep in my heart, out hope that they would love my mom's potato salad as much as I did, I made a vat of the stuff.  I filled the biggest bowl I owned.  It was perfect.  I had, of course, the requisite potatoes, eggs, mayo and mustard plus a pile of diced pickles, onions, celery, carrot and radishes.  It was colorful and flavorful and beautiful.

No one ate any of it.

Actually, I think my mother-in-law had a tablespoon of it, just to be polite.  But I returned home that evening with the whole vat still nearly compete, save only the polite tablespoon and the heaping spoonful I devoured.  I ate the rest of that salad for the next week at least. I later learned that because of the colorful look, the others in the family weren't interested.  It wasn't what they were used to, so they didn't even try it.  And several years later, I learned that generally this family doesn't even really like potato salad at all, much less potato salad that was so different from what they were used to.

I haven't really been asked to bring potato salad to anything since.  I usually get the chips and drinks request in stead. That has been the case for the last nineteen years.  Until this weekend.

Monday night, the Fourth of July, we planned on getting together for our monthly family birthday dinner, this time to celebrate my mother-in-law's birthday later this month.  Plus five teenage boy cousins and fireworks and you have a pretty raucous crowd.  A summer party, to be sure!

In planning for the family birthday dinner, MIL told me she was bringing fried chicken--which is delicious--and the rest of the girls (read: her daughters and me) were bringing salads.  Now, she did leave it wide open here, and I was kind of craving some mid-summer potato salad, and with delicious fried chicken there is nothing better, really.  So I told her I'd love to bring some potato salad.

Over the phone I could hear the concern in her voice. She was polite as ever on the subject, but she happened to mention to me to remember that it would probably be just her and I and my brother-in-law who would eat it, so don't make too much.  Okie dokie, I assured her.

A few days later, a couple of details had changed, so MIL called me again.  While I chatted with her about the changes in the plan, she mentioned, again, very politely "You know, the ingredients in potato salad as a lot like my macaroni salad that everyone just loves.  Maybe you would rather bring that instead?"  I reassured her that I'd prefer some potato salad and it would be no problem.  She still sounded worried as we hung up the phones.

The more I thought about it, the funnier it was to me.  And I finally figured that I would pull a fast one.  I headed down to our local favorite grocery store and bought a bucket of deli potato salad and then for Monday's BBQ I arranged it in my own covered bowl and sprinkled paprika on it whole thing.  It looked lovely, but very normal.  I brought it to the party.

We gathered that night at the home of our married niece, so her 2 year old can stay on her schedule, in her own bed, and miss the raucous crowd once her bedtime came. Genius Golfer was, well, golfing in a tournament that day so he didn't show up until almost 7 PM.  The rest of the family was at least 45 minutes late, and I had to get The Girl back to our neighborhood for her to help take down the flags the Young Women put up in the yards of our ward members for their fundraiser.  She and I were hoping to eat early enough to then sit around and visit until she had to go home.

Once everyone started showing up, EVERYONE showed up.  Our extended family and the niece's husband's family.  Come to find out, the niece's husband's extended family was invited for a BBQ and volleyball party and fireworks. No coordination for food was worked out.  We didn't know the other side was coming over. We were all celebrating at the same location--but we were celebrating two different family events.


Awkward. That is all I can say about that.

But the meal was laid out and blessing was said, and the loading of plates began.  I got looks of acceptance and appreciation for the potato salad we brought.  I even heard a great-grandma from the opposite family even ask about the potato salad to which my MIL cheerfully replied "My daughter-in-law made that."  The Great-Grandma seemed to imply it was really very tasty.

I ended up with just a couple of serving of potato salad left--perfect for my lunches this week, as still no one at my house will eat it.  I just miss the radishes, pickles and celery.  But the story will be worth that in a few more years, I think.

No comments: